April 19, 2014

A Solution to the Wage Gap?

Introduction

U1382971

On Wednesday April 9, 2014, Republicans blocked the Paycheck Fairness Act which would have forced businesses to make their employees publicly report their earnings to show the unfairness in the wage gap along gender and race lines.

However, before this bill was blocked, President Obama issued two executive orders on Tuesday, April 8: one bans employers from punishing their workers who discuss their pay with other workers, while the other requires employees to submit data that divide pay scales among gender and race. These executive orders only apply to federal contractors.

One statistic shows that women earn 77 cents for every dollar men earn, but the ratio alternates between different states. Many Democrats have been in favor of changing this statistic by means of the Paycheck Fairness Act, while Republicans shoot it down arguing that the bill is duplicative and would encourage many lawsuits.

Is it the Federal Government’s job to pass a bill that balances the wage gap? Do you think that businesses are intentionally biased and want to underpay women for the sake of limiting the businesses’ expenses? If not, why are businesses underpaying women in the first place? Is it wrong that businesses are underpaying women or do they have a right to? If it is not up to the Federal Government, who should regulate the unfairness in the wages or should it not be regulated at all?



 

Debaters


Statements

HPC2
No, Gender Wage Gap is Not a Problem At All

2 min read

First, the gender wage gap is not a significant social problem; I am even inclined to say it is not a problem at all. Since the passage of the Equal Pay Act in 1963, the treatment of female workers has improved remarkably.

Do the Feds Have to Intervene?

4 min read

On April 8, President Obama issued two executive orders, one banning employers from punishing their workers for discussing their pay with other workers, the other requiring employees to submit data that divide pay scales among gender and race. 

Gender Wage Gap, or Parenting Wage Gap?

2 min read

This week I was handed a complex topic. Congress had been engaged in fierce debate concerning the gender wage gap. 

A Century of Pointless Debate

4 min read

In light of the recent Republican filibuster of the Paycheck Fairness Act, the generations-old question of government interference in private commerce has again taken center stage: in other words, reared its ugly head.